Updated 15 November 2026 · About 8 minutes to read
A good multiple-choice question tests one idea, can be answered by someone who knows the material without seeing the options, and can't be guessed by someone who doesn't. Here is how to get there, with before-and-after examples.
The parts of a question
- Stem — the question or incomplete statement.
- Key — the correct option.
- Distractors — the wrong options. Their job is to attract people who hold a specific misunderstanding.
1. Put the whole problem in the stem
Someone who knows the answer should be able to answer before reading the options. If the stem is a fragment like “Fire extinguishers:”, the options have to carry the question and every option becomes a separate true/false judgement.
Before Fire extinguishers:
After Which type of extinguisher should you use on a fire in an electrical panel?
Keep the stem short, but include any condition that matters (“in a commercial kitchen”, “under the 2026 policy”). Avoid extra story that doesn't change the answer — it tests reading speed, not knowledge.
2. Ask about one idea
If a question needs two facts to answer, a wrong answer doesn't tell you which one the person missed. Split it into two questions. This also makes your per-question statistics meaningful: you'll see exactly which topic people struggle with.
3. Write distractors from real mistakes
The best wrong options are things people actually believe. Sources:
- Answers people gave when you asked the question as an open question.
- Common errors you see on the job (“I thought gloves replace hand-washing”).
- Correct statements that answer a different question.
Avoid joke options and options nobody would pick: they only reduce a four-option question to a three-option one. Three good options beat four with a filler. Research on item writing has found three well-written options work about as well as four or five, and they are faster to read.
4. Don't give the answer away
Test-wise people use clues that have nothing to do with the topic. Check for these:
- The longest option is correct. Keys tend to be longer because they carry qualifications. Make all options similar in length and detail.
- Grammar clues. “An …” followed by options where only one starts with a vowel.
- Repeated words. The key repeats a word from the stem; the distractors don't.
- Absolute words. “Always” and “never” usually mark a distractor. Avoid them, or use them in the key too.
- Position. Authors tend to put the key in the middle. Shuffling options (ExamKit can do this per attempt) removes position clues completely.
5. Avoid “all of the above” and “none of the above”
“All of the above” can be answered by spotting two true options. “None of the above” tells you the person knows what is wrong, not what is right. Neither works when options are shuffled. If several answers are correct, use a multiple select question instead and say “Select all that apply”.
6. Write positive stems
“Which of these is NOT …” questions are easy to misread under time pressure. If you must use one, put the negative word in capitals or bold, and keep it rare.
7. Choose the right question type
| If you want to know whether people… | Use |
|---|---|
| can pick the correct action from plausible alternatives | Single choice |
| know every item on a checklist | Multiple select (all-or-nothing or partial credit) |
| know a fact that is clearly true or false | True/false — but keep these few: a coin flip gets 50% |
| can recall a term without a prompt | Short text with a list of accepted answers |
| can calculate something | Numeric with a tolerance (for rounding) |
| can explain or apply in their own words | Essay, graded by a person |
8. Add an explanation
One or two sentences on why the key is right (and why the most tempting distractor is wrong) turns a test into a learning moment. In ExamKit you can show explanations after submission — or keep them hidden if the test is used again.
9. Review with numbers after the first run
After 20–30 people have taken a test, look at each question:
- % correct above about 95% — too easy to tell anyone apart. Fine for a must-know safety fact; otherwise make it harder.
- % correct below about 30% — either the topic wasn't taught, or the key is wrong. Check the key first.
- Discrimination near zero or negative — people who did well overall got it wrong as often as (or more than) people who did poorly. That usually means an ambiguous stem or a second defensible answer.
If you find a wrong key in ExamKit, fix it on the results page and regrade: every attempt of that version is rescored and certificates follow the new result.
Checklist before you publish
- Can the stem be answered without the options?
- Does each question test one idea?
- Is every distractor something a real person might choose?
- Are options similar in length and grammar?
- No “all/none of the above”, few negatives?
- Is there exactly one defensible key (or a clear “select all that apply”)?
- Does it have a short explanation?